Homemade Jelly Sweets
Quick answer: Dissolve a sachet of sugar free jelly and 2 sachets of gelatine in 284 ml of boiling water, pour two thirds into silicone moulds, chill briefly, then top with the remaining third mixed with fat free yogurt and vanilla. Chill for 4 hours. Each sweet is about 8 calories.
- Prep: 15 minutes
- Cook: 0 minutes
- Serves: 24
- Calories: about 8 per sweet (24 sweets)
These homemade jelly sweets are made with sugar free jelly, gelatine and a layer of fat free yogurt. Fill the moulds only partway so there is room for the yogurt layer. They need 4 hours to set. Gelatine is made from animal products, so they are not suitable for vegetarians.
Written by Matt, Matt’s Cafe.
Jump to: Recipe card · How do you make jelly sweets at home? · Are these jelly sweets vegetarian? · Why use sugar free jelly? · Why do I fill the moulds partway? · How long do they keep? · Can you use fruit yogurt? · How many calories are in homemade jelly sweets?

How do you make jelly sweets at home?
- Put the sugar free jelly and gelatine in a measuring jug with ½ pint (284 ml) of boiling water and stir until fully dissolved.
- Pour one third of the mixture into a separate jug and set aside.
- Pour the rest into silicone sweet moulds, filling them only partway to leave room for the yogurt layer.
- Chill the moulds in the fridge for 15 minutes.
- Meanwhile, add the fat free yogurt and vanilla to the jug with the remaining third and mix until combined.
- Take the moulds out of the fridge and top up with the yogurt mixture. Return to the fridge for 4 hours.
- Carefully press the sweets out of the moulds.
Are these jelly sweets vegetarian?
No. Gelatine is made from animal products. A vegetarian version would need a different setting agent, which I have not tested.
Why use sugar free jelly?
It keeps the calories very low. Check the label if you are watching sweeteners.
Why do I fill the moulds partway?
The yogurt layer goes on top. If the first layer fills the mould, there is no room.
How long do they keep?
Up to 4 days in the fridge in an airtight container.
Can you use fruit yogurt?
Yes, but calories rise. Check the label and recalculate.
How many calories are in homemade jelly sweets?
About 8 calories each. The full batch is about 180 calories: 1 sachet of Hartley’s sugar free jelly 6, 2 sachets of gelatine about 80, 160 g of Tesco fat free yogurt about 88 and ½ tsp of vanilla 6. Divide by 24.
Homemade Jelly Sweets
24
Sweets15
minutes8
kcal270
minutesEasy homemade jelly sweets made with sugar free jelly, gelatine and fat free yogurt in silicone moulds. About 8 calories each. Makes 24, set in 4 hours.
Ingredients
1 sachet Hartley’s sugar free jelly
2 sachets powdered gelatine
284 ml boiling water
160 g Tesco fat free yogurt
½ tsp vanilla extract
Directions
- Put the sugar free jelly and gelatine in a measuring jug with ½ pint (284 ml) of boiling water and stir until fully dissolved.
- Pour one third of the mixture into a separate jug and set aside.
- Pour the rest into silicone sweet moulds, filling them only partway to leave room for the yogurt layer.
- Chill the moulds in the fridge for 15 minutes.
- Meanwhile, add the fat free yogurt and vanilla to the jug with the remaining third and mix until combined.
- Take the moulds out of the fridge and top up with the yogurt mixture. Return to the fridge for 4 hours.
- Carefully press the sweets out of the moulds.


More recipes
Leave a comment below if you try this, or tag me on Instagram.
One tested recipe, a seasonal pick and a reader favourite, every week.

Just what I need to quell my urge for gums.